VVV earnings / call
VVV earnings call transcript, November 19, 2026
Valvoline's 4Q 2026 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast
- Kevin 12%
- Lori Flees 6%
- Laurie 6%
- Management 5%
- Elizabeth Clevenger 2%
Management
Kevin
Management
8 min
Lori Flees
President and Chief Executive Officer and Director
4 min
Laurie
Management
4 min
Elizabeth Clevenger
Investor Relations
2 min
Analysts · 1
- T
very confusing
the base oil cost environment
<1 min
Transcribed automatically by Lician from the company's public webcast; it can contain errors and speaker names are best effort.
- Prepared remarks0:04
Thank you for joining us, and welcome to Vavoline's third quarter, 2026.
- Operator
VVV earnings conference call. After today's prepared remarks, we will host a question and answer session. If you would like to ask a question, please press star one to raise your hand. To withdraw your question, press star one again. I will now hand the conference over to Elizabeth Clevenger, Investor Relations. Elizabeth, please go ahead.
- Elizabeth ClevengerInvestor Relations
Thank you.
Good morning and welcome to Vavilane's fourth quarter fiscal 2026 conference call and webcast. This morning, Vavilane released results for the fourth quarter and fiscal year ended September 30th, 2026. This presentation should be viewed in conjunction with that earnings release, a copy of which is available on our Investor Relations website at investors.vavilane.com. Please note that these results are preliminary until we file our Form 10-K with the Securities and Exchange Commission. On this morning's call is Lori Fleiss, our President and CEO, and Kevin Willis, our CFO. As shown in the accompanying presentation, any of our remarks today that are not statements of historical facts are forward-looking statements. These forward-looking statements are based on current assumptions as of the date of this presentation and are subject to certain risks and uncertainties that may cause actual results to differ materially from such statements. Valvoline assumes no obligation to update any forward-looking statements unless required by law. In this presentation and in our remarks, we will be discussing our results on an adjusted, non-GAAP basis unless otherwise noted. A reconciliation of our GAAP to adjusted, non-GAAP results and a discussion of management's use of non-GAAP and key business measures is included in the presentation. Appendix. I'll now turn it over to Laurie to begin today's call.
- LaurieManagement
Thanks Elizabeth and thank you all for joining us this morning. 2026 is a milestone year for Valvoline. We delivered our 20th consecutive year of same store sales growth, an achievement that few retailers can claim. That consistency has endured through a financial crisis, a global pandemic, and a wide range of economic conditions. This year also marks our 40th year in retail services. And for the first time, we surpassed $4 billion in annual system-wide store sales. These milestones reflect the strength of what we've built and the durability of our business. Our growth track record is a credit to our team members and franchise partners who deliver the quick, easy, and trusted service our guests count on every day. To everyone across our system, I want to thank you. We delivered strong results in fiscal 2026, and we did so while managing through a dynamic macro environment. Let's first look at what we saw in the fourth quarter. Starting with supply, despite broad industry disruption, we maintained the product availability we needed to serve our guests throughout the quarter. Given our scale and strong strategic supplier relationship, we continue to feel good about our supply position. As expected, the Group 3 base oil supply constraints drove a significant increase in finished lubricant costs in Q4. The company pricing actions we discussed on our last call were sufficient to cover the additional product costs we experienced during the quarter on a dollar basis. And our franchisees took additional pricing actions to offset their higher cost in the quarter. Outside of product costs, we remain disciplined in managing labor,
store expenses, and SG&A. Consumer behavior has been consistent. The demand for our services remains resilient. We continue to see transaction growth across the system. That reflects the essential nature of vehicle maintenance and the strength of our value proposition. Even as customers become more value conscious, they understand the importance of maintaining their vehicles. Our customer retention improved year over year for each customer type, including our existing customers, new customers, and fleet customers. Our customer satisfaction was also up. Net promoter scores are above 80 and we've earned an average 4.8 Google star rating across our network. We're encouraged by the strength of our existing customer relationships and our ability to keep guests coming back. Our premium lubricant mix continued to grow and we've seen no changes in trade down behavior. Also, the rate at which customers added non oil change services held stable year over year. However, as we shared in August. We continue to see pockets of softness and growth most notably at stores and lower income areas where households are facing tighter budgets. This is largely attributable to slightly lower levels of new customer acquisition. On the network side, our growth was strong in the quarter with 61 additions, 33 company operated locations and 28 franchise locations, which brings our network total to 2,517. As we approach the one-year mark, we're pleased with the progress we're making on the Breeze integration. This quarter, we converted another 16 stores to the Valvoline brand, and we remain confident in the value this acquisition is expected to deliver. With that, I'll
turn it over to Kevin to walk through more detail on our fourth quarter and full year adjusted results.
- KevinManagement
Thanks, Lori, and good morning, everyone. I'll start with the financial highlights for the fourth quarter, all of which were in line with our expectations. Net sales increased 22% to $555 million. This growth reflects momentum in the core business and the contribution from Breeze. Same store sales. Growth for the quarter was 9.4%. Transaction growth was flat to slightly positive. Ticket delivered a majority of the comp. Net pricing, premiumization, and NOCR were all positive. Contributors. Gross profit margin decreased 300 basis points year over year at the low end of the expected decline we shared on our last earnings call. About a quarter of the decline came from a temporary lag in passing the full cost increases through to franchisees which was resolved in the quarter. Labor was slightly higher as a percent of net sales although we saw labor leverage in our company operated stores. SG&A as a percent of net sales improved 50 basis points year-over-year to 17.2 percent. That reflects the benefit of top-line growth along with continued cost discipline across the business. We continue to focus on improving operating leverage while supporting the growth of the business and navigating the macro environment. EBITDA increased 10 percent to $144 million, with adjusted EBITDA margin decreasing 280 basis points year-over-year to 20.3 percent.
EPS decreased to 42 cents per share, primarily due to higher interest expense related to the Brees acquisition and a higher tax rate, which included state taxes tied in part to our network expansion. For the full year, we delivered strong results meeting or exceeding our updated guidance. These results reflect solid execution throughout the year, including our ability to manage the significant product cost increases while delivering on our financial commitments. System-wide, same-store sales grew 7.9% at the upper end of our guidance range. Across the system, we saw modest transaction growth. While ticket drove the majority of the comp. We added 337 stores across the system. Net sales reached $2.1 billion within our guidance range. Adjusted EBITDA of $557 million was above the mid. Point and adjusted EPS of $1.76 per share exceeded the top end. Capital expenditures were below the low end of the range at $228 million. This reflects the timing of store additions and conversions as well. as lower store conversion costs. Free cash flow was $204 million more than four times our fiscal 2025 level. Breeze performed ahead of our expectations for the year with revenue and EBITDA contribution. exceeding our outlook. The headwind to EBITDA margin was about 20 basis points, well below what we initially anticipated, reflecting operational improvements, early delivery of GNA synergies, and the impact of Earth.
Early marketing and fleet initiatives, we made meaningful progress to strengthen our balance sheet. We ended the year at 2.6 times net debt to adjusted EBITDA from the combination of adjusted EBITDA growth during fiscal 2026 and debt reduction. Our recent leverage-neutral refinancing extended our debt maturity profile and enhanced our liquidity, leaving us with meaningful financial flexibility and no near-term debt maturities. We also increased the share repurchase authorization to $500 million. And are committed to resume repurchases following this earnings release, subject to market conditions. We made significant progress towards remediating the previously disclosed material weakness, and we expect to report in our upcoming Form 10-K. that it has been remediated. Overall, we exited fiscal 2026 with strong earnings, significantly improving cash generation and a healthy balance sheet, positioning us well as we enter fiscal 2027. With that, I'll turn it back to Lori to talk about our priorities for fiscal 2027.
- Lori FleesPresident and Chief Executive Officer and Director
Thank you, Kevin.
As we look ahead to fiscal 2027, we remain confident in the fundamentals of our business and our ability to execute in a dynamic environment. Our strategy is unchanged. We're focused on driving the full potential of the core business, delivering sustainable network growth, and innovating as customer and vehicle needs evolve. So let me spend some time on our focus areas. for fiscal 2027. Within the core business, our work is straightforward. Drive transactions, grow ticket, and improve margin. Our outlook assumes no change in the supply environment. Stable product availability and continuation of elevated product costs. Our team will keep executing with discipline and staying focused on serving our customers. We expect customer demand will remain resilient. While the fundamental need for preventative vehicle maintenance is on changed, we are planning for an environment where consumers remain value conscious. Therefore, we'll continue to adapt our approach to drive transaction growth as market conditions evolve. In 2027, we'll launch our national advertising fund across the system, which we expect to increase brand awareness and improve marketing efficiency in driving more traffic to our stores. Regarding ticket, we'll be disciplined in our pricing actions. In the near term, we'll protect gross profit dollars. while supporting long-term customer relationships. We have a long track record of managing price through changing cost environments and will monitor consumer behavior and adjust as appropriate. Beyond price, we expect premiumization to support ticket.
growth as the car park evolves and will continue to benefit from non-old change service penetration opportunities. On margin, while the cost environment will continue to put pressure on our margin rate, we'll advance the margin improvement work already underway across the business. including GNA labor management and store operating efficiencies. We expect these efforts to improve productivity as we scale and to deliver improved performance over the longer term. Network growth remains a priority. across both our company operated and franchise businesses. Our pipeline remains strong and we're making progress on our commitment to lower new unit and conversion capital costs. In fiscal 2027, we plan to add 190. to 220 new stores across the system with franchise locations representing roughly half of those additions. We'll complement that growth with the conversion of Breeze stores to the Valvoline brand. Looking at the evolving needs of our customers in the car park. Fleet continues to be an important growth opportunity for us. In fiscal 2026, Fleet revenue saw high teens growth driven from both higher ticket and healthy transaction growth. That transaction growth is coming from both our expanded store network and increased fleet penetration at existing stores. We expect to build on that momentum in fiscal 2027. We're confident in the fundamentals of the business and the opportunities ahead.
We've demonstrated our ability to execute through challenging conditions and that discipline will remain important in the year ahead. I'll turn it back over to Kevin to walk through our financial outlook.
- KevinManagement
Thanks Lori.
Our outlook calls for continued growth in fiscal 2027. We expect same store sales growth of five to seven percent on a full year basis. At the beginning of the year, we expect same store sales to run at the. High end or potentially above our range before moderating toward the low end as we lap pricing actions taken in fiscal 2026. Our guidance for net sales is two point two five to two point three five billion. Our adjusted EBITDA range is five hundred and ninety five to six hundred and twenty five million dollars with adjusted EPS of a dollar eighty five to two dollars and five cents per share capital expenditures. are expected to be two hundred and forty five to two hundred and sixty five million dollars. This outlook reflects a few key assumptions. On the top line, we expect same store sales transaction growth across the system to be roughly flat for the year. We assume product costs will remain elevated throughout the year and expect pricing adjustments to offset any further increases on a dollar basis. For the full year, gross margin deleverage is expected. We expect it to be approximately 100 basis points with product cost pressure partially offset by labor leverage. In the first half, we expect margin deleverage to be approximately 200 to 250. 50 basis points moderating throughout the year. Below the gross profit line, we are planning for SG&A leverage. At the midpoint of the ranges, implied EBITDA margin is about 50 basis points lower.
Compared to fiscal 2026. Similar to prior years, we expect to deliver approximately 40 to 45 percent of adjusted EBITDA in the first half of the year. Our profit guidance reflects a range of outcomes for the year. The high end of the range incorporates improving consumer trends, leading to higher transaction growth and positive NOCR penetration growth. Moderating product costs would also be a benefit. The low end contemplation. Plates softness expanding into higher income households, which could cause lower transaction growth and or lower penetration of non-oil change services. Our capital allocation commitments remain the same. Invest in the business, maintain a healthy balance sheet, and return capital to shareholders. We remain committed to the free cash flow target we shared at our investor update, four to five times our fiscal 2025. Consistent with this, I'm pleased to confirm that subject to market conditions, we will resume share repurchases once our trading window opens following today's release. Returning capital to shareholders remains a project. Priority and resuming repurchases reflects the strength of our balance sheet and our confidence in the cash and earnings generation of the business. I'll mention a couple of additional items for modeling purposes. Interest expense is projected to be 105 to 110.
- Q&A17:02
- KevinManagement
million dollars for the year, and we expect our adjusted tax rate to be approximately 26.5 percent, which is in line with fiscal 2026. With that, I'll turn it back to Lori to wrap up. Before we open the call to questions.
- Lori FleesPresident and Chief Executive Officer and Director
I'd like to make a few closing points. The fundamentals of our business are strong. Our services keep vehicles on the road and our guests continue to trust us to deliver those services. Our results this year show the dirt. We'll continue to navigate a dynamic macro and cost environment in fiscal 2027. We'll remain focused on execution to deliver profitable growth. That means taking care of our guests. Supporting our team members and franchise partners, and delivering on the commitments we've made to shareholders. I'm confident in the strength of our business, and I'm confident in our ability to keep creating long-term value for our shareholders.
With that, I'll turn it over to Elizabeth to begin the Q&A.
- Elizabeth ClevengerInvestor Relations
Thanks, Lori.
Before we start the Q&A, I'd like to remind everyone to limit your question to one in a follow-up. With that, the operator can open the line.
- Operator
Your first question from the line of Stephen Shemesh with RBC Capital Markets. Stephen, your line is open. Please go ahead.
Good morning.
Thank you for taking the question, and congrats. On a strong print. Wanted to ask on demand elasticity. Maybe if you could just comment on, you know, you put a good, a fair amount of pricing into the market. I know it's less than you did a couple of years ago. But how is the consumer responding to that? And I guess specifically as we think about transactions, if you could give us any color on how those trended throughout the quarter. And when we look to 2027, if you expect those two to stay positive. And then I just have a follow up. Sure. I'll cover some of the elasticity and then Kevin, you can cover the cadence question. It's a good question, Steve. You know, I think you have to step back and remember that Valvoline competes on convenience speed. And trust. And we have, we have to certainly watch our pricing, but it's not the first driver for consumers and for fleet customers on the brand that they choose. That said, whenever you take pricing and increases, and when we look back at history of when we've taken pricing increases over 5%, you do expect some elasticity. But that's, but that's very, it's been very, very small. In our historical events, and we would expect the same to be true. When you raise price, there are a couple things you look for right away as indicators. You look for trade down, meaning customers who OEM does not require or recommend full synthetic, but the customer is getting it anyway. Do they choose to trade down to something lower? Or do they change the number of services that they add on to the oil?
And that's the piece that we've been watching very closely. And as I commented on the in the prepared remarks, we're not seeing that trade down or the NOCR fall off. So deferral and switching. Within four and six months, when we look at our retention rates, again, as I mentioned in the prepared remarks, our retention rates are up year over year. And every month since we've taken the price increases, they're up year over year. So we're not seeing any elasticity effects yet. We obviously will continue to watch them. But in the past, when we've had them, they're very, they're very minor. They're not material. And when you look at the net impact of the price increase, plus a little bit of transaction fall off, you end up driving more growth, both on the top and the bottom line. So we're feeling pretty good right now around elasticity. It's not to say that we won't see it and we're not expecting it, but we've fully put that in our expectations. And I'd comment on the transaction side. We commented in the prepared remarks for Q4. Kind of a continuation into fiscal 27 that ticket drove the majority of the comp. Transactions were up modestly. As we commented last quarter, we did see softness. And in stores that have a lower income customer cohort around them, that softness continued into Q4. And our outlook presumes that that continues into fiscal 27. Well, so that's really what we see from a transaction perspective. On a gross transaction view, we would expect to grow transactions in 27 at or slightly above where we grew total transactions in fiscal 26.
That's great.
Thank you very much.
And separately, it's been almost a year now since you closed on Breeze. Maybe if you could just give us an update on how those stores are performing too. Relative to initial expectations. Yeah, thanks. Breeze has obviously been a big focus for us this year, having acquired over 160 stores and really added to the port. I think we've been pretty transparent the entire year since we've closed that we're making really good progress, that we're actually pleased with the progress, both in terms of the underlining business, but also the talent. We've converted another 16 stores in Q4, obviously very early on, but the performance of those stores is in line with our expectations. And the performance overall of Breeze has been driven by operating efficiency. We have had to take pricing actions, just like the entire industry within Breeze, and we were able to do those. In advance of the cost increases that were coming. And then we have had really good progress in the synergy capture. And that will continue as we continue to convert stores and pull that. Team and the systems more fully into Valvoline. So really pleased with the progress so far, both of the store performance pre-conversion, post-conversion, and then just of the overall. Integration and synergy. And just to add a bit to that, when we close the transaction for the full year, we expected Breeze to be about a 100 basis point drag on the EBITDA market.
And we're really pleased that as we finished out the year, there was only about a 20 basis point impact, which reflects the solid performance of the business, some of those early G&A synergies that Lori talked about. And it gives us really just even more confidence in the value creation opportunity that the business offers as we continue to convert those stores and integrate them into the Valvoline system.
Yeah, that's great. Thank you. Best of luck moving forward.
Thanks, Steve.
- Operator
Your next question from the line of David Bellinger with Mizuho.
David, your line is open. Please go ahead.
We can't hear you, David.
Hey, can you hear me now? Yes. Sorry about that.
Good morning.
Thanks for the question.
I want to ask about gross margins, which are down pretty meaningfully in the quarter. How should we think about the Q1 gross? Cost margin rate versus Q2 if the first half is supposed to be down between 200 and 250 bps. And then what's bridging the gap to get to the full year down 100 bps? Is that something internal or is it more external just given the move? So the outlook presumes that base oil prices, finished lubricant prices cost remains elevated throughout all of fiscal 27. So we're basically we're basically assuming that the environment we've been in and that we are in right now continues throughout the full fiscal year. As as we as we think about margin progression, we would we would expect that you know q1 is typically our it's our it's our seasonally lowest quarter generally so we we would expect that margin compression to be bigger in q1 and then moderating throughout the course of the year but for the first half as indicated approximately 200 to 250 basis points so you know think of it as probably toward the high end of that and early on and then moderating over the course of the year I think as you as you look at it for the full year the the hundred basis points of gross margin compression is is pretty much all around product cost we're not presuming that that we take significantly more price than we have seen cost while obviously we look at price you know very consistently and do price testing etc and and kind of setting that aside for the moment it's kind of an all things being equal as we look at fiscal 27 we think that as as we do the math for the full year we'll see that we'll see the margin continue
to improve it's always better in the second half simply because that's that's our busier time of year but as you look at it on a full year basis primarily due to product cost and the compression related to that based on the price we've taken which offsets that product. We just expect the full year to be about 100 basis points. Great great thanks for all that detail. I wanted to follow up on maybe a bigger picture picture question about agentic commerce and how this is. Playing into lead generation. Have you seen any impact in traffic coming into your site, maybe in terms of new customers? And how is Valvoline thinking about LLMs and the way your brand surfaces in this new channel? That's a great question, David. One is we are doing a lot of work making sure that we have content, which the LLMs will source. And so... One, making sure that our site presents itself in a way that the LLMs will use. But another big piece of that is the Google star ratings and the customer feedback that comes through with that. And that's something we've been really focused on. We used to do... our own surveys to get customer satisfaction. And what we recognize is that Google star ratings is such a key influence of new customers. And it definitely is the... piece that runs into the agentic AI tools. And so we are very well positioned on that front. And we're now working to augment the other pieces of content that the LLMs will turn to.
Very helpful.
Thank you both.
- Operator
Your next question from the line of Mark Jordan with Goldman Sachs. Mark, your line is open. Please go ahead.
Hey.
Thank you very much for taking my question. You know, looking at SG&A and 4Q, it came in much better than expected. Can you talk about what drove the improvement there and maybe how we should think about incremental drivers of improvement as we move into 27?
Sure, Mark. Yeah, there's been a lot of disciplined execution around SG&A, and that's been helpful, and we expect that to continue to be helpful as we have as we grow our SG&A leverage into fiscal 27. It's been a big focus for the team. A lot of work has gone into that, and there's still room to improve, and we fully expect to improve in 27. I think to be balanced. Obviously, we have taken price, and so we've seen top-line growth, which actually helps with that SG&A leverage as well. But on an overall basis, it's just been a... a lot of really hard, detailed work by the team to focus on areas where we can become more efficient, we can take work out of the system, do more with less, et cetera. And the team's done a really, really good job with that. We expect that to continue. We do expect there's room to continue to build that leverage. Perfect.
Thank you very much.
And then just following up, one, on the store growth expectations for 27, commentary implies about 100 or so openings on the franchise side. And I think, you know, that compares to, you know, a previous target that was out there of 150 for 27. So can you just talk about maybe what factors are contributing to lower growth there? Yeah. Overall, Mark, I would... say that we're really pleased with where we landed last year. Even in the quarter four, we had a really strong quarter of 61 new ads. And it was a very strong quarter for our franchise partners. There's still a lot of white space. The pipeline of our franchisees and the company side, but on the franchisees in particular is very strong and we, our franchise partners continue to invest in capital to build out their markets. This past year was a record year for the year in terms. of new store additions, excluding transfers. Um, and we have been working with our franchise partners to build up their new real estate and construction capability because ground ups have to be. A critical component to getting to the target, um, new additions for them of 150. Um, and, and really good news in FY26, when you look at the new ads, given it was an outsized year. The ground ups were 70% of those new units, which is really, um, a positive, you know, trajectory for us and the, and the brand. Um, and when we set the goal of getting to. 150 new units, um, on the franchise side, we, we did that four years ago and we had a lot of work to do, which I think we've made a lot of progress. One, we had to lock in new development agreements, which we did, and we just locked in four more for, for.
Canada, which is the first time we've had development agreements for Canada and commitments of capital in the country with incentives all tied around it like we've done in the US. We've had to bring on new partners. into our system, both to take over systems that already exist and to create new ones, which we've done. And then we've really been focused on working with them to build up their real estate and construction capability. And I think that's the piece that has proven a little bit more challenging. We've got a couple of franchise partners that have had to reset their team capabilities, but I think we've got good teams in place. We've been working very collaboratively with them. And so we have line of sight of getting to the 250 units. I think in this year, the 190 to 220 with half, you know, coming from franchise means 100 to 110, you know, on the franchise side. And we do have the commitments to get there. Now we just have to support them. to execute to get them. Excellent.
Thank you very much.
- Operator
Your next question from the line of Max Rocklenko with TD Cowan. Max, your line is open, please go.
Go ahead. Great.
Thanks so much and congrats on the nice quarter. So first question, can you, can you discuss any changes to the frequency of how you price to franchisees given this unique period? And if now we should. Think about gross margin purely as mathematical on pricing to maintain dollars and not rate and then ahead that there shouldn't be any sort of timing impacts that you saw previously. And then just when can we. How do you stand out compared to the prior comments of five to seven dollars in price that you've taken?
I'll take that one, Max. In terms of of the changes that we've made around how we priced a franchisee. The concept is unchanged. We are protecting what I would call the dollar margin there. We did make a change in terms of that process. We did that in Q4. We talked about we did get a little bit behind because the run-up in cost was faster than the pass-through, and we've changed that process so that we have very, very little lag, I would say. Right now, it's very, very small, and I think another key point, while this isn't a predictor of the future, we've actually seen product costs remain pretty stable for the past few weeks. Which is encouraging. Again, not necessarily a predictor of what might come, but we're happy about that. Stable product cost is kind of good for us all the way around. It's good for our franchise partners, too. We don't really expect any kind of meaningful timing difference in terms of what and when we pass through to the franchise partners to the extent that we see our costs go up or down. And so I think we feel really good about that. We had a small wagon in Q4 which we corrected with process change and we feel good about that going forward. In terms of the five to seven dollars per oil change, there's really no difference. We expected finished lubricant costs to go up about 60 percent. We priced accordingly for that and our pricing actions have recovered all of that cost and that's been pretty stable as well. So we're at parity today.
Versus where we thought we would pay something. And Max, the only thing I would add to that is our franchisees, as we passed on cost to them in the quarter in Q4, they also took pricing. Their pricing increases on a percentage basis were in line with where company had taken, and we talked about last quarter. Got it. That's very helpful. And then just figure picture, how are you thinking about the medium term EBITDA margin power of the business compared to the analyst day? If we assume that eventually base oil prices do come down and you hold on to price, and then as you mentioned earlier on the call, the headwind from the breeze has also been meaningfully less than you previously expected. So just any comments there as we think medium to longer term. And Max, we continue to feel good about our medium term outlook that we that we gave not quite a year ago at our at our investor update. We feel like we're on track. We're still executing against all the things we talked about at the investor update in terms. of margin expansion, et cetera. Obviously, the math where we are today with product cost and the pricing we've taken has caused margin compression on a percentage basis. Again, reminder, we are. Protecting margin dollars and growing margin dollars as we grow the business, and we continue to feel good about the actions that we're taking, the results of those actions, and how that's going to drive us to those numbers.
those commitments we made back in December of last year. Yeah, so Max, we made a commitment of 100 to 200 basis points of improvement in EBITDA margins. When you take out the impact of the cost and price changes that have been made, we're still on track to have those leverage points. And I think if you assume that product costs start to dissipate, and we, again, have historically the industry doesn't move backwards on price, assuming that that holds, which we have no reason to believe otherwise, that margin improvement should be towards the high end of that range, if not more, but it's going to take time for the supply situation to get to a point where the product costs start to come down. So we'll be ready for that. We're still delivering the leverage items, the work that we're doing to get more leverage on G&A and operating costs, so that that is making a meaningful difference. Obviously, the product costs sort of cloud the issue on the actual calculation. Great.
Thanks so much and best regards. Thank you.
- Operator
Your next question from the line of Brett Jordan with Jeffries. Brett, your line is open. Please go ahead.
Hey, good morning, guys.
Are you still feeling as... If product costs come down, you will not have to give back all of the price that has been taken. I mean, obviously, I think you said finished lube costs were up 60%. You've largely offset that. I think last quarter we sort of talked about prices don't generally come down. as much as the input might. So does the market feel like it? Yeah, so far, you know, as I mentioned in the prepared remarks, the consumer behavior has remained consistent despite the pricing increases. So when we look at our retention rate, when we look at our NOCR attached rate, et cetera, things are very stable. I think the question will be around, you know, I don't think we'll want to bring prices down. The question is, is will we want to use some of the margin to drive more customer acquisition in the environment? That's going to drive more top line. And more profit. So I think we'll always be weighing those things off and what's going to drive the long term value of the business. The reality is, is when we go out and acquire customers, you know, the whole point is we get them back and we get them back repeatedly over time. And that becomes a flywheel to drive more earnings through the growth. So I don't, based on everything we're seeing, we wouldn't see a need to pull back. On price, we can drop that to margin without, you know, doing promotional activities, or we could drive some promotional, you know, marketing spend to acquire more customers, which is going to drive more profit. So net net, it's going.
It's going to be a positive. OK, I guess from a competitor standpoint, you're out copying your peers pretty significantly. Do you see them using price as a tool to try to catch back up or, you know, will the. Or be discounting in the broader market? That sounds like no. Yeah, I mean, I just remember that the old change category is very fragmented. So there are very few competitors who if they decide. To do promotional impacts that would or promotional kind of activities that will impact our entire network. We see discount levels in Q4 were relatively consistent and that was through the pricing cycles. On a percentage basis which is actually pretty typical in our industry is a dollars per ticket goes up the discounting percentage typically stays relatively flat for a period of time and then you can optimize within. And some of that is because in the store you'll have a customer react and the and the team wants to maintain that relationship and again these are things that we have a long track record in managing and we've we've factored that in. And that was factored into our Q4 number and guidance and it's factored into our fiscal 27 we have heard of discounting activities, but we're not seeing anything major or broad across the network, I would say that we're pretty well. positioned to take share in the supply environment and to be honest you know what we're hearing is others are not growing transactions and we're still having very healthy transaction growth and even positive.
on a same store sales basis. I'm not sure we're hearing that from our competitors. Okay and then non-oil change revenue you said it was sort of flat year over year is there anything new on the non-oil change menu or is have you trotted anything else out or is it pretty. much the same offerings yeah nocr penetration rates are relatively stable and that you know that takes a lot of work from our team and really executing on the process and educating customers. The fact that so much of our business comes from repeat business our customers actually know what to expect and they've been educated on the needs of their vehicle. When we look at fleet penetration you know our fleet penetration continues to grow and they are less they are less inclined to defer on any of those services so all of those things really bode well. We have a few things that we're testing in terms of we've had customers and franchise partners have already offered some premium filters. Oil changers had that offering as well and so we have started to to pilot offering premium filters for customers who, again, want to invest in taking care of the maintenance of their vehicles. That presents, you know, a very small upside. I wouldn't say it's all in our numbers. It's not meaningful. Obviously, if it is, we'll let you know and we'll update our numbers. Numbers accordingly. But overall, we continue to learn from breeze. We continue to learn from our franchisees and listen to our customers and will adapt some of our services as a result.
Great. Thank you.
- Operator
Your next question from the line of Mike Albanese with Stonex. Mike, your line is open. Please go ahead.
Yeah, thank you.
Good morning, guys.
Thanks for taking my question.
Yeah, just another quick one here on pricing. I mean, I think you laid out your expectations pretty good. You know, plan to kind of hold price and rebuild margins if oil costs come down. And historically, this model has been able to do. that. I guess I just want to take it one level deeper here and just get some sense on what you would need to see that would make you kind of, you know, take pause or change your strategy and say, hold on, we need to give back some price. And, and rebuild traffic. I mean, is it simply, you know, flipping negative? I think you said your midpoint on transactions next year is flat. Is it going negative and staying negative for consecutive months or quarters? I mean, how do you think about, you know, what you would need to see to kind of shift gears? Yep. Good question. So really we look at retention and if we start to see any significant changes out of the ordinary on customer retention, that's when I think we have to look at our pricing and whether or not that's a driver or whether it's other issues. Again, our retention has improved year over year. The promotion side or how you discount. And we've been doing a lot of work on offering the right discount at the right time to the right potential customer. And obviously with new customers, when you are facing customers that feel very constrained from a spend perspective, it's typically not the time that they're going to try something new unless you give them something compelling, a compelling reason to do it. And that's the area where we have to
continue to adapt and figure out the right approach to new customer acquisition in the environment and in those markets that have more value, higher value conscious consumer base.
us but also in the industry. Okay. All right. And then just a follow up quick one on breeze here. Obviously you said it's running in line with your expectations, if not better. I think when you first bought. The 160 stores, they were doing about 1.1 million in average AUVs. You know, can we kind of maybe quantify this a little bit? I'd be curious as to maybe some of the earlier stores that you integrated, how that 1.1 million has grown or is tracking. Relative to the, you know, nearly 2 million kind of overall system average. I'll take that one, Mike. For the 28 stores that we've converted, it's still early days, but we are seeing... Positive momentum, and they are performing at or slightly above where we would expect them to be based upon what we would normally do for stores that we acquire. As a reminder, we will buy 30 to 40 quick lubes per year and convert those to the Valvoline brand, and then they start climbing the curve, and generally those stores do reach. The AUV that we would expect and that we enjoy in our overall store base. And it's really a combination of things. Number one, there's a marketing playbook that we implement that helps drive that. It brings in new customers. It really drives the transaction growth in those stores. Number two, the Valvoline brand is very strong. It's well recognized. That tends to bring in traffic as well. Number three, we have a very longstanding approach to how we train our teams and how they execute.
in the store with our customers. That's very, very consistent, which not only drives traffic on the front end, but also keeps those customers coming back and really drives the very high retention rate that we enjoy. All of those things in combination help these. stores and should help the breeze stores climb the curve. They're very, very similar to many stores that we would acquire with the exception that, frankly, they are generally better, better operated than many of the stores we would acquire on a onesie or twosie. basis throughout the course of the year. And so they already have a very strong base from which to grow. They just need the Valvoline playbook training systems and brand to actually make that come to fruition over the course of time. Sure. That's great. Is it generally a linear progression? So generally, year one, you'll see a little bit of a dip as we invest in the as we invest in the store. Profit and profit. That's right. Sales, sales, sales will go up. Profit will go down a little bit because we're investing in the team, we're investing in marketing, etc. But then it becomes pretty linear from there in terms of the the maturity curve after it's about three years of linear and then you'll get improvements in your four and five. But to a lesser extent, it's a it's a typical ramp is what we're expecting for our our new arc. conversions. Awesome.
Thanks so much, guys.
Thank you.
- Operator
Your next question from the line of Kevin Condon with Baird. Kevin, your line is open, please.
Go ahead. Hi.
Good morning.
Thanks for my question.
Taking my question as well. A bit of a follow-up to the prior question, but in fiscal 2027, as some of those brews stores start entering the comp equation, is that a tailwind to same-store sales, just as those small stores grow and benefit from the rebranding? Or, I guess, given your comments on the EBITDA drag being less than 2026 and some of those integration improvements? We've been sitting earlier. Is the comp uplift from the maturation of that store maybe less than a typical curve? Yeah. So, as a reminder, we converted 28 stores in fiscal 26, we would expect those stores to enter the comp in our Q2. So, typically, it's a year after acquisition that a store would enter the comp, and so that would imply the beginning of our Q2. And, again, as a reminder, it's 28 stores on a base of 2,500-plus stores. So, while we would expect it to be a tailwind, it'll be very, very small at this point. But we do expect those stores to contribute. Yeah. It'll be small and growing over the time we integrate. So, as we continue to integrate stores in 27 and they enter the comp, it'll obviously build over time. But it'll be fairly small at the start of the year. Gotcha. So, it's a year after you convert the stores to the, to the Valvoin brand that they start filming into that comp equation. So, it's a, sorry. No, it, it, the way to think about it is is we acquired debris stores on December 1st of last year. And so, December 1st of this year will, will mark one year that we've owned them. And we converted 28 stores in fiscal, during fiscal 26. And so, those 28 stores.
We'll enter the comp basically at the beginning of our Q2, which is the March quarter. So, come January, those stores will be part of the comp because we will have owned them for a year by then. And so, that's, that's the way to think about that. In-store sales comp guidance is based on Valvoline instant oil change stores in the United States. It has excluded Canada and it will exclude the oil changers branded stores. So, it'll just be Valvoline branded stores. stores in the U.S. and only stores that we've owned for one year or more. So, consistent with the definition that we switched to. Thank you. Sure. Your next. Question from the line of Scott Stembler with Roth Capital Partners. Scott, your line is open. Please go ahead.
Good morning.
Thanks for taking my questions as well.
We're trying to get a sense of. Um, you know, some of the areas that you saw in certain markets weakness, um, trying to get a sense of, of, of a cadence, uh, if we've seen things get worse as the quarter progressed, just trying to. Get a sense of how sensitive, uh, these customers in the, I guess, in these lower income markets are as they really feel the full, you know, brunt of, uh, these, you know, increased. Yeah. I, I, I don't think it's so much around the price change of oil changes. I think these are customers that broadly are feeling constraints from the macro inflation. And in Q4, we also recognize that people are making a variety of choices, particularly around the holidays. And so we, we've also factored. Given the fact that in times where people are making trade-offs, they may defer until next quarter services that they are due if they're not finite. So we anticipate customers in lower income demographics. To be making certain trade-offs in Q4. But the reality is, is they're not trading off maintenance. The behavior, you know, customers understand the importance of maintaining their vehicles. And part of this is driven by the cost that it. Would be to upgrade their vehicle. So buying a new used vehicle, the cost of car loans, et cetera, is very prohibitive versus where many people are today. Or the cost of major repairs. So it's a timing issue for some of these customers, not necessarily not going to do it at all. And so I don't think we see this getting worse.
For an extended period of time, obviously, if the economy, you know, something that we're not forecasting and the pressure becomes broader, we don't see our customers behavior change. We're not changing all that much and our numbers based on small changes are not highly sensitive. At a company of our size, that actually works in our favor.
And then just last question, going back to Bree's integration and synergies, you know, one of the synergies that we've talked about is they're adopting, you know, fleet services and the non-oil change. You know, NOCR. Can you just talk about how those trends are going, particularly as, you know, things are, you know, within the market have tightened up? Yeah, great question. Integrated our fleet teams probably about four months ago. We fully integrated them in this quarter. So our fleet team now is working on behalf of the entire network and we have sort of in our national fleet accounts, we've included breeze sites in all of the accounts that we could do so given the way that they bill and that those contracts are arranged. So we're seeing some good momentum though we're in early days around the breeze stores. It's much easier once we convert them, but we have done quite a number of things to try to get some of that growth earlier and that's contributing to some of the breeze momentum that we saw in the year on NOCR on NOCR. Oh, sorry. I was just saying NOCR, they do a They did a pretty good job. We've been working across services that Valvoline offers that they don't, services that they offered that we didn't on the Valvoline side. In some cases, we are picking up some offerings, as I mentioned, premium filters as an option for our guests. That's something that some of our franchise partners have already done and oil changers did. So we'll get the benefit of that.
across our system. And then on the oil changer side, we're trying to work through, and I think we've decided not to add services into oil changers until we convert them. And part of that is the systems list that you have to make. in order to add those things into your offering. So I think we're just trying to pace, is the juice worth the squeeze, or do we wait until we convert the store? And I think we've decided that adding things to the oil changer stores will be probably to a minimum until we convert the stores. Great.
Thanks again.
- Operator
Your next question from the line of David Lance with Wells Fargo.
David, your line is open. Please go ahead.
Hi.
Good morning, guys.
And thanks for taking my questions. So you mentioned fleet penetration continues to grow and that revenues for that segment, you know, grew high teens and 20 in fiscal. So curious if you can size that contribution to the 7.9% comp for the year and what you're embedding for the 27 outlook. David, as you look at the fleet business, it's still growing very well. We're incredibly pleased with how that is progressing. But as a reminder, it still represents under 10% of total system-wide sales. Again, growing very quickly, but still relatively small, which gives us. A lot of encouragement around the opportunity now and into the future as we continue to grow that business. But I think the way to think about it is it's growing faster than the system, but it's still less than 10% of the system. And so it will be a contribution. But it's still relatively small in terms of the percentage of contribution. Got it. That's helpful. And then just two more quick ones. Can you talk about the cadence of openings throughout the year in 2027, as well as, you know, the cadence of comps through, you know, fiscal Q4 and anything that you're seeing on a quarter to date basis?
So in terms of the cadence of comps, currently we're enjoying obviously price that's ahead of where we were last year and will be for the first half of the year. So we would expect the comp to be at or even initially above the high end of the 5% to 7% outlook range that we've given for the first half of the year. And then moderating as we start to lap the pricing that both we and our franchise partners took in Q3 primarily for us and Q4 more so for them. It could take us more to the call at the low end of that range probably for the second half of the year. Your other question was around the cadence of store openings. So I think we have a there's a seasonality to the way. that new store openings happen. We typically in Q4 because of the timing of summer and construction, as well as the timing of M&A that's going to hit by the end of the year. We typically have a pretty good Q4. Then it goes lighter and we tend to be very back-end loaded. And we've tried hard to pull that forward and be less back-end loaded. But the reality is, is construction cycles and M&A don't always align up well with that. So I think you should think about the cadence to be consistent if you look back over the last three years with kind of where we are. You've been on average. Thank you.
- Operator
Your next question from the line of John Babcock with Barclays. John, your line is open. Please go ahead.
All right.
Good morning and thanks for.
Thank you for taking my questions. I guess just first on product costs, I want to get a little clarity here. So I think you were targeting up 60% by the end of the quarter. If you could just confirm that's where you were. And then also how much are costs up now relative to the same starting benchmark? You know from I think the prior to the end of the last quarter. So in the in the quarter we we basically. It came in as expected product finished lubricant costs were up about 60%. And to be very clear, the pricing that we have taken has covered that cost increase. And so we feel very good about where we are there. I would say for for the last few weeks product cost. Has been pretty stable. We've seen some upward movement in the base oil index for for group three. But to be clear, the base oil index and the spot market are are still very, very disconnected. And we haven't seen a lot of change from a spot market perspective. But yeah, and we're and we're happy about that. Less volatility is good. Obviously, we're looking forward to seeing costs go go the other way once once. The supply chain frees up over the course of time. But you know, but for now, product costs have been very stable for the last few weeks. And that's a good thing. Okay, so it's fair to say that it's costs are basically up a little bit from the end of the quarter, but not up significantly. No, they're really not up versus the end of the quarter. It's been pretty stable for the last, you know, call it four to six weeks. Relative to the average for the quarter, they're slightly up. But for the exodus, they're seeing a lot of stability.
And we're not expecting any significant changes on the supply side, both to the positive or the negative. But we certainly will adapt if there are changes and we're ready for that. Okay. And the next question, you know, I know like fuel prices don't always tend to, you know, fully recover back, you know, for whatever reason. I'm just wondering, you know, and I know you don't have a lot of precedence.
In terms of, you know, the market and like where it is today. So maybe this is a bad question. But just generally, do base oil costs tend to fully recover when crude oil costs come down? Or, you know, what sort of movement do you tend to see? I would say over the over the course.
What we're in right now started started to unfold that those two those two things had disconnected themselves again eventually and over the course of time, it will match up. But as you as you look at base oil, it's a supply demand. Phenomenon, really. And right now, we're still tight, especially in group three. And even as you see even as you see crude oil futures and gasoline prices, which do tend do tend to to track pretty quickly and pretty closely. As you've seen those things change, again, the base oil market really hasn't changed. And that's all about supply and demand, especially in group three, which remains tight. And for now, it's not just about oil flow. It's also about refining capacity. And some of the refining capacity, it's shut down because of the lack of supply. And it will take time for that to get back up and running once supply lines are fully loaded. So I think that that's also part of the disconnect that we that work. planning for. So we we're taking the approach in FY27 that the environment remains the same as it relates to supply and cost. And I think overall we're we're ready to execute within that and deliver really good profitable growth. That's very helpful. One last one, if you don't mind me squeezing this and just, you know, obviously you had like really good cost control during the quarter, you know, and it sounds like you're continuing to target, you know, costs across.
The company, do you have any specific cost reduction targets that you have for the year or, you know, maybe you prefer not to go down that route? Yeah, we prefer to not go down that path. I mean, we're continuing. To work internally with the team to find efficiencies in the system and to execute against those. But we don't have any targets that we've talked about publicly. It's really all about executing well, continuing to find. Those efficiencies and then execute on those. Okay, fair enough.
Thank you so much.
- Operator
Your final question from the line of Stephen Zaccone with Citi. Stephen, your line is open. Please go ahead.
Question · the base oil cost environment
Tvery confusingAnalyst · the base oil cost environmentGreat. Thank you. It's very confusing with the base oil cost environment. I imagine it's very difficult to manage this as well. But I guess simple question here, right? If we think about base oil cost kind of staying the same, right, and being stable, at what point would the gross margin rate get back to a level you were before we had all this disruption?
- Management
Yeah, I think the way we're looking at it right now, as we've said in our outlook, we're expecting total gross margin compression for the full year of 100 basis points. And the implication is, as we said, approximately 200 to 250 basis points of compression kind of in the first half. And you could infer that Q1 would be at the high end of that. And over the course of the year, we expect that to moderate. So I would say all things being equal, if they ever are, things being equal, we would expect to close that gap probably towards the end of the fiscal year, most likely, based on where our outlook is.
- Management
Okay, that's very helpful.
- Management
Thanks for that.
- Management
The final one I had was just on the national advertising campaign. So I guess you're having a little bit of an expansion this year in terms of the fund, but maybe just talk about would that result in a comp list? Like, how do you think through that? Yeah, a great question. So on the company side, in 26, we talked about flipping some of our local brand spend to national advertising, and we did see efficiency benefits on that. Particularly in the fourth quarter. In FY27, our entire system will start our national advertising fund, which will, you know, when you look at our financials, it'll show that advertising costs are up at a greater rate, but this is more franchise funds flowing through and us spending them. So it's going to look a little odd on the P&L, but it is really just a franchise control. that we're distributing to an advertising fund that we manage on behalf of the system. And that increase in spend is going to drive more impressions at a much lower cost, which then drives better efficiency in the lower funnel. And what does that mean, lower funnel? We get more people coming to, you know, search for Valvoline, come to Valvoline-owned sites to you know, to learn more about our product and come to our stores where we're not paying for that traffic. And so that that's going to allow us to use the money more wisely to actually attract and acquire more new customers into the system. And that's part of the reason why when Kevin talked about total growth in transactions, we expect total growth in transactions to be the same or higher in this fiscal.
- Management
year than 26. And some of that is driven by what we believe will happen in the National Ad Fund. Now, obviously, we will look to overperform, but we're early on and in this. And so as we learn, we'll obviously update. our expectations. Okay.
- Management
Thanks for that detail, Laurie.
- Management
That's a pleasure. Thank you. We have reached the end of the Q&A.
- Operator
This concludes today.
Thank you for attending.
- Operator
You may now disconnect.