Should I Buy EXR Stock in 2026?

Data-driven analysis and honest assessment for Extra Space Storage Inc

Analysis Updated:
CAUTIONSeveral concerns warrant careful consideration

Current Price: $140.37P/E: 31.1

Decision Score

4.9/10

Weak

Based on 6 fundamental factors

Score Breakdown:

Valuation (20%)5/10

Elevated P/E of 31.1

Growth (20%)3/10

Declining -0%

Profitability (20%)4/10

Thin margins (0% net)

Financial Health (15%)5/10

Financial health data limited

Cash Flow (15%)8/10

Strong FCF yield of 5.1%

Insider Activity (10%)5/10

No recent insider activity

Key Investment Metrics

Current Price

$140.37

P/E Ratio

31.14

Revenue Growth

0.0%

Profit Margin

0.3%

Market Cap

$30.8B

Dividend Yield

0.05%

How EXR Compares to Competitors

Understanding how EXR stacks up against peers helps inform your investment decision.

How EXR Compares to Peers

Upcoming Events for EXR

+5 Reasons TO Buy EXR

1. High gross margins of 75%

strong

Gross margins above 50% typically indicate strong brand value or intellectual property moats.

2. High free cash flow yield of 5.1%

moderate

FCF yield above 5% means substantial cash generation for dividends, buybacks, or reinvestment.

-5 Reasons NOT to Buy EXR

1. Thin profit margins of 0.3%

high risk

Low margins provide little cushion against cost increases or pricing pressure.

2. High PEG ratio of 3.6

high risk

PEG above 2 suggests expensive relative to growth rate.

3. Premium valuation at 31x earnings

medium risk

P/E of 31 requires sustained growth to justify. Multiple compression risk exists.

4. Minimal revenue growth

low risk

Growth of 0.0% barely keeps pace with inflation.

Who Should Buy EXR?

Investment Profile

Risk Level

Medium

Recommended Holding Period

3-5 years

Best For:

    Not Suitable For:

    • Growth Investors

      Limited 0% growth may disappoint

    • Value Investors

      Premium P/E of 31 doesn't fit value criteria

    • Income-Focused Retirees

      Low 0.0% yield

    Consider These Alternatives

    If you're interested in EXR, compare these Real Estate peers:

    Pro tip: Compare EXR directly with competitors using our comparison tool to see which stock better fits your criteria.

    Get the Full Picture

    Access AI-powered insights, DCF valuations, insider trading data, and real-time analysis for EXR

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What is EXR stock price today?

    EXR (Extra Space Storage Inc) stock is trading at $140.37 as of the latest market data. Stock prices update in real-time during market hours (9:30 AM - 4:00 PM ET).

    Is EXR stock going up or down today?

    EXR stock price movements are influenced by market conditions, news, earnings reports, and investor sentiment. Check our live dashboard for real-time price changes and technical indicators.

    Should I buy EXR stock now?

    The decision to buy EXR depends on your investment strategy, risk tolerance, and financial goals. Our AI analysis evaluates fundamentals, valuation metrics, growth prospects, and market conditions to help inform your decision.

    Is EXR a buy, hold, or sell right now?

    Our AI-powered analysis provides buy/hold/sell recommendations for EXR based on multiple factors including valuation, growth metrics, technical indicators, and analyst consensus. Visit our dashboard for the latest recommendation.

    Is EXR stock overvalued or undervalued?

    EXR currently trades at a P/E ratio of 31.14, which may indicate premium valuation. Our DCF calculator provides intrinsic value estimates to help determine if EXR is fairly priced.

    What is EXR's P/E ratio?

    EXR has a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 31.14, which measures how much investors are willing to pay per dollar of earnings. Compare this to industry peers and historical averages for context.

    What is EXR's market cap?

    EXR (Extra Space Storage Inc) has a market capitalization of $30.85 billion, making it a mid-cap stock.

    What is EXR's price to book ratio?

    EXR trades at a price-to-book (P/B) ratio of 2.17, which compares the stock price to the company's book value per share. A P/B below 1.0 may indicate undervaluation, while above 3.0 may suggest premium pricing.

    Similar Investment Decisions

    Explore investment analyses for stocks similar to Extra Space Storage Inc

    Explore Categories

    Disclaimer

    This analysis is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. The decision score and recommendations are based on quantitative factors and do not account for all risks, your personal financial situation, or qualitative factors. Always do your own research and consider consulting with a financial advisor before making investment decisions.